The Peach Bellini Margarita is Earls Kitchen + Bar’s bridge between two familiar drinks. It has the soft white-peach flavor people associate with a Bellini, but tequila, triple sec and lime put the structure firmly in margarita territory. Basil gives the finish a fresh green aroma rather than another layer of sweetness.
That distinction matters at home. Add prosecco because of the name and the drink becomes thin and fizzy. Use peach schnapps as the main fruit and it turns candy-sweet. The current Earls description points toward a cleaner build: real peach texture, sharp lime and a small amount of basil over an agave-spirit base.
What Earls Actually Serves
Current Earls menus in Canada and the United States list the Peach Bellini Margarita under the margarita section. They consistently describe tequila, triple sec, white peach, fresh lime and basil. The tequila is not universal. Canadian location pages often name El Tequileño blanco, while U.S. menus checked use Patrón Silver.
The listed pour at several Canadian restaurants is 1.5 ounces. Exact allocations between tequila and triple sec are not published, so this copycat uses one ounce of tequila and half an ounce of orange liqueur. That keeps the total spirit measure aligned with the menu while giving the peach and lime enough room.
Availability is current as of November 2026, but pricing changes by city. Menus checked range from about $16.25 CAD to $18.50 USD, with happy-hour discounts at participating locations. Treat those as examples, not a chain-wide fixed price.
Why Typical Peach Margaritas Miss
The first problem is peach schnapps. It supplies fruit, sugar and alcohol at once, which makes it difficult to control the drink. White peach puree tastes softer and more floral, and it lets triple sec provide a distinct orange edge.
The second problem is over-muddled basil. Crushing several leaves releases dark, vegetal flavors and leaves green bits floating through the drink. Two small leaves shaken briefly are enough. Save the prettiest sprig for the garnish, where its aroma has more impact.
Finally, bottled margarita mix overwhelms white peach. Fresh lime has a cleaner acidity, and agave can be adjusted to the ripeness of the fruit. Start with the recipe’s quarter-ounce, then add a bar spoon only if your puree is unusually tart.
The Key Technique: Blend, Then Double-Strain
Make the puree before building the cocktail. Blend thawed white peach until completely smooth, adding only a teaspoon of water if the blades will not catch. Push it through a fine strainer if the skins or fibers remain noticeable.
Once the drink is shaken, strain it a second time through a fine-mesh strainer. This removes torn basil and coarse peach pulp without stripping away the fruit’s silky body. Use fresh ice in the glass; the broken shaker ice will melt too quickly and flatten the peach.
Clap the garnish sprig once between your palms. That releases surface oils without bruising it into the drink, so the first impression is fragrant basil followed by peach, lime and tequila.
Make a Pitcher for Eight
Combine 8 oz blanco tequila, 4 oz triple sec, 6 oz white peach puree, 6 oz fresh lime juice, 2 oz agave syrup and 5 oz cold water. The water replaces the dilution that individual shaking would provide. Refrigerate for up to four hours and stir thoroughly before serving because peach settles.
Pour about 4 oz over fresh ice in each rocks glass. Do not batch basil leaves in advance; extended contact makes the pitcher taste grassy. Garnish each glass with a freshly clapped sprig and a thin peach slice instead.
The Peach Basil Margarita Mocktail
Simply removing the spirits leaves sweetened peach and lime with no middle. Strong chilled green tea restores some tannin and dryness. Orange juice echoes the triple sec, saline sharpens the fruit, and a short sparkling-water top lifts the puree.
Brew the tea at double strength and chill it fully so it does not melt the ice. If the peach is very ripe, omit the agave on the first shake and sweeten only after tasting. The finished mocktail should still lead with lime and finish with basil, just like the cocktail.
See more restaurant copycat cocktails →
