Pappadeaux’s Guava Banana Mai Tai is a short tiki sour sitting on a seafood menu that also sells big frozen swirls. The ingredient line is specific: an unaged volcanic rhum agricole, a banana liqueur, a house guava orgeat and fresh lime. That is enough to build a serious drink at home, and not enough to call any ounce measure the restaurant’s own.
In November, when a lot of holiday pouring leans on whiskey and cream, this is the bright glass. Guava and lime cut through fried catfish and rich gumbo without tasting like a beach punch.
What Pappadeaux Actually Lists
The chain’s drink menu dated October 6, 2025 places the Guava Banana Mai Tai with the fruity cocktails. The printed ingredients are Rhum J.M Terroir Volcanique, Clement Bana Canne, house-made guava orgeat syrup and fresh lime juice. The same page lists the Swamp Thing separately, as raspberry and melon liqueurs layered with a frozen hurricane and a frozen margarita. So this Mai Tai is not a frozen drink and not a fruit-juice highball.
Clement’s producer describes Bana Canne as a banana liqueur at 25% ABV, built on rhum agricole. That detail matters. A heavy cream-based banana liqueur, or a syrup with no spirit, will not behave the same way in the shaker.
Pappadeaux was still promoting the cocktail in February and April 2026. The October 2025 menu does not print a price, and this draft could not confirm a November 2026 location price or that every restaurant still pours it. Treat the ingredient list as documented and the availability as something to check locally.
The menu also lists a zero-proof drink called Burst of Paradise: guava puree, lemon juice and club soda. A February 2026 post from the chain called that drink the zero-proof cousin of the Mai Tai. It does not include orgeat or banana, which is why the mocktail below adds both and says so.
Why Typical Mai Tai Copycats Miss This One
Most Mai Tai recipes in circulation are either the 1944 Trader Vic sour or a tall glass of rum, pineapple juice and orange juice. Both miss the drink Pappadeaux named.
The 1944 pattern wants aged Jamaican rum, orange curacao, orgeat, a touch of rich syrup and lime, shaken and served over crushed ice. The Trader Vic’s Mai Tai follows that line. Pineapple and grenadine never belonged there. They also are not on Pappadeaux’s ingredient list for this drink.
Using a dark, molasses-heavy rum is the other miss. Terroir Volcanique is an agricole, distilled from fresh cane juice, grassy and saline rather than caramel-sweet. If the bottle you have smells like brown sugar and vanilla, you are making a pleasant rum sour with guava. You are not making this one. A Martinique or Guadeloupe blanc is the right substitution. An aged agricole can work in a pinch, but it will taste rounder and less sharp.
The last miss is treating “guava orgeat” as a splash of guava nectar on top of a sweet bottled orgeat, then adding more sugar. Nectar plus a full measure of orgeat plus banana liqueur turns the lime into a spectator. The puree has to be measured.
The Key Technique: Build One Syrup, Then Shake
Pappadeaux has not published the house syrup. The practical home version is 1/2 oz (15 ml) orgeat stirred with 1/4 oz (7 ml) unsweetened guava puree. Almond still leads. Guava colors the drink and adds a musky tropical note. If the puree is very thick, stir in a teaspoon of water so it blends instead of clumping.
Shake agricole, banana liqueur, that syrup and 3/4 oz (22 ml) lime with plenty of ice, then strain onto fresh ice. Shaking with the service ice and dumping it all into the glass leaves a watery drink by the third sip. A fine strainer keeps the puree from looking muddy.
Taste before you garnish. If the banana liqueur you bought is sweeter than Bana Canne, drop it to 1/3 oz (10 ml) and keep the lime where it is. If you only have sweetened guava nectar, use 1/4 oz (7 ml) orgeat and 1/2 oz (15 ml) nectar, and expect a softer drink.
A lime wheel is a home garnish. The menu does not list one, and a February 2026 caption’s use of “layered” reads like menu language, not a confirmed instruction to float the syrup. This recipe shakes everything together.
A Pitcher for Eight
Stir together 12 oz (360 ml) blanc rhum agricole, 4 oz (120 ml) banana liqueur, 4 oz (120 ml) orgeat, 2 oz (60 ml) unsweetened guava puree and 6 oz (180 ml) fresh lime juice. Refrigerate up to 24 hours. The lime will taste duller after that.
For each drink, shake 3 1/2 oz (105 ml) of the cold mix with ice and strain over fresh ice. Multiply the banana liqueur only after you have tasted one single. A sweeter bottle should be scaled down before you commit a whole pitcher.
Do not add soda to this batch. The cocktail is a sour. Sparkling length belongs to the mocktail.
The Burst of Paradise Cooler
The restaurant’s published zero-proof drink is simpler than the cocktail: guava puree, lemon and club soda. That is a good cooler and a thin copy of the Mai Tai. The mocktail here keeps those three ideas, uses lemon as the menu does, and adds 1/2 oz orgeat plus 1/2 oz banana syrup so the almond and banana survive.
Shake the thick ingredients, strain over ice, then add cold soda. Stir once. If you have no banana syrup, mash a thin slice of very ripe banana with the guava before shaking, and fine-strain harder.
Check labels if someone at the table is avoiding alcohol completely. Orgeat and banana syrup should be nonalcoholic, but flavored syrups occasionally are not. The cocktail version is a real drink, about 1.3 standard drinks, and the creamy texture of a sweet tiki sour can hide that.
See all Pappadeaux copycat drinks →
