Buffalo Wild Wings is a game-day room, and the drink that fits a November kickoff is not another frozen margarita. It is a short, cold Bloody Mary that tastes like the pickle spear on the garnish plate. Per the early-2026 nutrition guide, the chain’s spicy version is the Spicy Pickle Bloody Mary: tomato, brine, heat, and enough vodka to count as one drink rather than a dare.
A search for a “Blazin’ Bloody Mary” does not land on a current menu name. The August 19 to November 17, 2026 allergen guide lists the Spicy Pickle Bloody Mary and, at select locations, a B-Dubs Bloody Mary. Blazin’ remains a wing-sauce name. This recipe follows the drink the chain actually prints.
What Buffalo Wild Wings serves (per the early-2026 nutrition guide)
The early-2026 nutrition guide gives the Spicy Pickle Bloody Mary 140 calories, 1.5 grams of fat, 1,750 milligrams of sodium, 7 grams of carbohydrate, 2 grams of fiber, 3 grams of sugar and 2 grams of protein. That is a modest, savory cocktail. The sugar is low for a chain drink, and the sodium is high enough that pickle brine belongs in any serious copy.
What the guide does not give is a recipe. No spirit brand, no ounce measures, no garnish list. A separate location retail listing has described a bottled Signature Bloody Mary Mix as jalapeño, horseradish, Worcestershire and citrus, at 30 calories per 4 fl oz. That description fits the house style, but it was not labeled as the Spicy Pickle formula, so this home version builds the pickle drink from tomato juice and real brine instead of pretending the bottle is the spec.
An older item is easy to mix up with this one. In 2023 the nutrition guide listed a Make it Wild Bloody Mary, also at 140 calories, described on a menu site as Tito’s Handmade Vodka, signature bloody mary mix, spicy Wild sauce and garnishes. Wild is a hot wing sauce, not pickle brine. It was not on the 2026 cocktail list used here. Prices are local. The nutrition guide does not set a dollar amount.
Why Typical Spicy Bloody Marys Miss
The usual miss is heat without brine. Hot sauce on tomato juice tastes sharp for one sip and then flat. Pickle brine is acid, salt and dill in one pour. It is the reason the restaurant drink can show 3 grams of sugar and still taste finished. Leave it out and you will keep adding Worcestershire, which turns the glass muddy.
The second miss is a heavy vodka pour. Two ounces of 80-proof vodka is already about 128 calories before any juice. The printed drink is 140 calories total, so the spirit has to stay near 1½ oz. More vodka makes a stronger cocktail. It stops being a copy of the number Buffalo Wild Wings published.
The third miss is shaking. A hard shake aerates tomato juice into a pale foam and bruises the horseradish into a bitter cloud. Stir, or roll the drink once from one tin to another if you want it colder. Stop when the outside of the glass sweats.
Celery salt on the rim looks traditional and pushes an already salty drink over the edge. A pinch in the glass is enough. The spear can carry the rest of the salt.
The Key Technique: Brine First, Heat Second
Measure the pickle brine before the hot sauce. Cold brine from the jar tastes cleaner than brine that has sat out with garlic and peppers. If the jar smells harsh, use a fresh dill pickle and a measured splash, not the last cloudy inch.
Drain the horseradish on a spoon for a second so you are adding the root, not a puddle of vinegar. Half a teaspoon is enough to bloom in 4 ounces of tomato juice. Lemon keeps the tomato bright. Bottled lemon mix is sweeter than this calorie count allows.
Stir for 10 seconds with plenty of ice, then taste. Add one more dash of hot sauce only if the brine is quiet. The goal is a savory pint you can drink next to wings, not a shot of pepper.
A Pitcher for Game Day
For 8 drinks, combine 12 oz (360 ml) vodka, 32 oz (960 ml) tomato juice, 6 oz (180 ml) dill pickle brine, 4 oz (120 ml) fresh lemon juice, 4 tsp prepared horseradish, 16 dashes Worcestershire and 16 dashes hot sauce. Add a scant ½ tsp celery salt and a few grinds of pepper. Stir, cover and refrigerate for up to 24 hours. Do not put ice in the pitcher.
The horseradish gets louder as it sits. Stir again before service. Pour about 6 oz (180 ml) of cold mix over fresh ice in each pint. Set pickle spears and lemon wedges out so people garnish their own. Keep the pitcher in the refrigerator. Tomato and brine should not sit in a warm cooler through a game.
The Zero-Proof Pickle Mary
Skip the vodka and add a touch more brine. The alcohol in the full cocktail is only 1½ oz, so the flavor was never hiding behind a large spirit. Tomato, lemon, horseradish and dill still read as a Bloody Mary if the salt is right. A non-alcoholic spirit is optional here and easy to overdo. If you want more body, 1 oz (30 ml) of a savory 0.0% vodka alternative can go in, and you should drop the extra brine back to ¾ oz.
Keep the same rule on heat. Two dashes, then taste. The mocktail has fewer calories, about 40, and it still carries plenty of sodium from the brine. Serve it in the same pint, with the same spear, so it looks like it belongs on the wing table.
See more Buffalo Wild Wings copycat drinks →
