The Red Hook is the rye drink that started a small map of Brooklyn neighborhoods in a Manhattan glass. Punt e Mes puts a bitter line through the vermouth. Maraschino adds cherry pit and a hint of almond. Neither one is there to make a whiskey sour. Stirred and served up, it is a strong Thanksgiving pour for people who have already had the cider.
Vincenzo Errico created it in 2003 at Milk & Honey, Sasha Petraske’s menu-less bar on Eldridge Street. He has said he wanted something between a Manhattan and a Brooklyn, and that a fellow Italian neighbor suggested the Red Hook name. The drink is older than the Greenpoint and a lot of the other neighborhood riffs that followed it.
What Milk & Honey Actually Served
The bar did not give you a menu. You talked to the bartender, and the bartender chose. That is why small arguments about garnish and exact brand linger on drinks from this room. There was no opening card with a printed price for the Red Hook, and both New York locations are closed, so there is still no price to quote.
The original address was 134 Eldridge Street. It opened at the turn of 2000 and poured through a last night around New Year’s Day 2013. Sam Ross and Michael McIlroy reopened that space as Attaboy. Petraske moved the Milk & Honey name to 30 East 23rd Street in January 2013. That larger room closed on October 25, 2014, when the building was set to come down. Asking Attaboy for a Red Hook is fair. Calling Attaboy Milk & Honey is not.
Errico’s account of the build, as Imbibe has reported it, is 2 oz rye, 1/2 oz Punt e Mes and 1/2 oz maraschino, stirred into a coupe. He has tied the drink to Punt e Mes showing up behind the bar, a vermouth with enough bitterness that people describe it as sweet vermouth plus a measure of amaro. The name Punt e Mes refers to that idea: a point and a half. Punch, publishing a recipe under his name, gives the maraschino as 1/4 to 1/2 oz to taste. Use 1/2 oz for the version he described in that interview. If the cherry shouts over the rye, the Punch range says you can come down.
No garnish is the clean serve. A brandied cherry shows up in some later recipes. It is fine beside the glass. It is not required to make the drink the Red Hook.
Why Typical Copycats Fail
Plain sweet vermouth in place of Punt e Mes is the change that looks harmless and is not. Carpano or a standard rosso makes a rounder, sweeter sip, closer to a cherry Manhattan. The bitter edge is the reason this drink got a new name. If Punt e Mes is unavailable, use sweet vermouth and cut the maraschino to 1/3 oz (10 ml), and know you have moved the target.
Too much maraschino is the second miss. This liqueur is potent. It smells like cherry pits and almonds, and a full ounce turns the rye into a flavoring. A half ounce is already the top of the published range. Measure it. Free-pouring “a splash” is how the drink gets sticky.
The third miss is a low-proof rye with both modifiers at full measure. Eighty-proof whiskey can make a lovely Red Hook, and it will taste softer and a little sweeter. The 100-proof bottle has the spine for 1/2 oz of liqueur plus 1/2 oz of vermouth. If you use the lighter rye, keep the maraschino at 1/3 oz or stir a few seconds longer.
Old vermouth belongs on this list too. Punt e Mes is still a wine. Refrigerate it after opening. Oxidized vermouth makes the cherry note taste like cough syrup.
The Key Technique: Stir Until the Cherry Sits Inside the Rye
Use cold, dense ice and a mixing glass with room to spare. Stir for about 30 seconds. The goal is a coupe that smells like rye first and cherry second. If you taste sugar before you taste whiskey, it is under-stirred or the maraschino is heavy, not “the style.”
Strain clean. Shaking clouds the drink and adds more dilution than the cherry liqueur can stand. Serve it up. On a big rock it looks like an Old Fashioned and drinks warmer and sweeter at the same recipe, because you have skipped the stir’s measured water.
One hundred proof is the assumption behind the 2.1 standard-drink figure. Rittenhouse is a useful example of that strength. It is not documented here as Errico’s original bottle. A bonded rye at the same proof behaves the same way in the math. Drop to 80 proof and you should tell your guests the drink is closer to 1.7 standard drinks, still strong, just not the number on this card.
Batch Eight Red Hooks
Combine 16 oz (480 ml) of 100-proof rye, 4 oz (120 ml) Punt e Mes and 4 oz (120 ml) maraschino liqueur. Seal and refrigerate for up to two weeks. The vermouth is why it goes in the fridge. Write the date on the bottle.
Stir 3 oz (90 ml) of the batch with ice for each coupe. Do not add more maraschino in the glass. For a freezer bottle, add 6 oz (180 ml) of cold water to the full batch, freeze until syrupy, and pour about 3 3/4 oz (110 ml) into a frozen coupe. Taste a small pour first. Freezer-cold amaro and maraschino can taste quieter than they did at room temperature, then bloom as the glass warms. Eight servings at this spec are about 17 standard drinks. Label the bottle that way.
The Cherry Hook Mocktail
Maraschino is the hard flavor to fake, and tart cherry juice alone tastes like fruit punch next to rye. A barspoon of orgeat adds the nutty, pit-adjacent note, and a pinch of salt keeps the cherry from turning sweet. The zero-proof red aperitivo covers the bitter wine role that Punt e Mes played. Zero-proof whiskey covers the base.
Stir it like the original and serve it up. Over ice, with extra cherry juice, it becomes a different, longer drink. If your aperitivo is already very bitter, the salt matters more than more cherry. Alcohol-free only: do not finish this one with a dash of standard bitters.
See more Milk & Honey copycat cocktails →
