Yard House runs a long beer list and a short, sturdy mule. The Moscow Mule on recent menus is New Amsterdam vodka, ginger beer, lime and mint. That is the whole sentence. No apple liqueur, no pineapple, no flavored vodka. Those show up in other mules on the same page, which is why this one is easy to overbuild at home.
It is also a November drink for practical reasons. Ginger and lime cut through fried food during a game, and a cold mug looks right on a holiday table that already has heavier whiskey drinks. The recipe is fast. The mistakes are all about sweetness and flat ginger beer.
What Yard House Actually Serves
Location menus describe the Moscow Mule as New Amsterdam vodka, ginger beer, lime and mint. Several current listings put it at 240 calories. A 2026 menu roundup priced it around $10.99 at that calorie count. An older printed menu for the West Nyack restaurant listed the same ingredients at 280 calories and $10.75. Both can be true of different printings. They should not be averaged into a fake official number. This copycat aims at 240 and says so when the pour changes.
The chain does not name the ginger beer. That missing brand is the largest variable in the glass. A sharp, dry ginger beer at 4 oz can sit under 240 calories with 1½ oz of vodka and ¾ oz of lime. A soda-sweet ginger beer can push the same pour toward the older 280. If your bottle tastes like ginger ale, the drink will taste like Yard House only in shape.
Two neighbors cause most of the confusion. The Grey Goose Strawberry Mule adds strawberries, and the Hawaiian Mule uses pineapple vodka. Adding that fruit to the plain mule makes a drink the menu already sells under another name. Yard House also prints a zero-proof Hibiscus Mule’ish with Seedlip Spice 94, ginger beer, hibiscus, lime and mint, around 150 calories. That is not this cocktail with the vodka skipped.
Why Typical Moscow Mules Miss
The first miss is a 2 oz vodka pour copied from a 1940s spec. That is a fair mule, and it is documented for other bars. It is a poor match for a chain drink printed at 240 calories. Vodka at 2 oz is about 128 calories before the ginger beer arrives. This recipe uses 1½ oz, which is 1.0 standard drink, and leaves the ginger beer room to be the point.
The second miss is too little lime. A wedge squeezed over the top is garnish, not juice. Three-quarters of an ounce is enough to keep 4 oz of sweet ginger beer from tasting like soda. A full ounce starts to taste like a sour if your ginger beer is already dry. Taste the beer first, then decide whether to stay at ¾ oz.
The third miss is muddled mint. Yard House lists mint as a garnish, in the same breath as lime. Slapping the sprig releases the oil onto the surface. Muddling it into the mug stains the ginger beer and adds a bitter stem taste by the last inch. Save muddled mint for a julep.
Chill the mug before you build. A warm copper cup full of wet ice waters the drink before the ginger beer is poured. A chilled highball is closer than a warm souvenir mug.
The Key Technique: Build Cold, Stir Once
Pour the vodka and lime onto fresh ice, then the ginger beer. Pouring down the side of a tilted mug keeps the bubbles. One lift from the bottom with a bar spoon is the whole mix. The lime will sit under the beer if you skip that lift. Do not keep stirring.
Use ginger beer that has been in the refrigerator, not the pantry. Warm beer foams over the rim and then goes flat in the time it takes to carry the mug to the table. Four ounces is a deliberate top, not “fill the mug.” A 16 oz copper cup will take 8 oz of beer if you let it, and the vodka will disappear. Stop at 4 oz even if the ice looks lonely. Add another cube instead of more beer.
Mint goes on last, after a clap between your palms. Lime wheel on the rim or dropped in. Both match the menu. A dehydrated wheel looks tidy and tastes like nothing. Use fresh.
A Batch That Still Tastes Carbonated
Ginger beer does not wait in a pitcher. For 8 drinks, stir 12 oz (360 ml) New Amsterdam vodka with 6 oz (180 ml) fresh lime juice. Bottle it and refrigerate for up to a day. That mix is 2¼ oz (67 ml) per drink, which is the 1½ oz of vodka plus the ¾ oz of lime.
Set the mugs, the ice and a cold supply of ginger beer where you are serving. For each drink, add 2¼ oz of the vodka-lime mix, fill with ice and top with 4 oz (120 ml) ginger beer. One stir. Mint and lime at the last second so the herbs do not blacken in a bowl of citrus.
For Christmas or a game, this is the right batch because the slow part is the squeeze, and you did that in the afternoon. If you want the older, stronger build for people who ask, keep a jigger out and add an extra ½ oz of vodka to that mug only. Do not “correct” the whole bottle or you will miss the 240-calorie target for everyone else.
The Zero-Proof Mule
Leave the vodka out. Keep the ¾ oz of lime and the 4 oz of ginger beer, and add a small pinch of salt. The salt does not make a savory drink. It keeps the ginger beer from tasting one-note once the alcohol is gone. Slap the mint the same way. You are copying the aroma of the cocktail, not building a new soda.
This lands near 140 calories, almost all from the ginger beer. Yard House’s own Hibiscus Mule’ish is the drink to make if you want theirs: it adds Seedlip Spice 94 and hibiscus and is listed around 150 calories. The plain mule mocktail is the closer twin to the Moscow Mule on the menu. Serve it in the same mug so it does not look like an afterthought during a game.
See more Yard House copycat drinks →
